When I first brought Elf on the Shelf into my classroom, I thought it would be a fun way to keep the holiday spirit alive for my students. The idea of hiding the elf each day, seeing the kids’ excitement, and creating a sense of wonder seemed like the perfect way to kick off the season. But reality hit quickly. Within a week, it turned from a magical experience into a daily struggle to manage chaos. Each morning, the kids would rush into the classroom, more focused on finding the elf than on the lesson I had planned. By the end of December, I was exhausted, and my students’ focus had drifted away from learning. That’s when I realized: maybe Elf on the Shelf isn’t all it’s cracked up to be—at least not in the classroom.
It Distracts More Than It Engages
The intention behind Elf on the Shelf is well-meaning: creating excitement, bringing fun into the classroom, and giving students something to look forward to. But what teachers like me quickly learn is that the fun can come at a cost. Rather than adding to the learning environment, Elf on the Shelf often becomes a distraction.
One year, I had students so wrapped up in finding the elf that it was nearly impossible to settle them into the day’s lessons. As soon as they arrived, the focus shifted from schoolwork to the elf, and it disrupted the natural flow of our school day. I wasn’t alone in this experience. Another teacher shared, “I did it one year, thought it would be fun, it was a nightmare.” What begins as a source of holiday excitement often turns into chaos that’s hard to manage, especially with already hectic holiday schedules.
Studies have shown that disruptions like this can reduce valuable instructional time. A study from the University of California found that frequent classroom interruptions negatively impact student engagement and learning outcomes. While Elf on the Shelf may create excitement, it often comes at the expense of focused learning, making it hard to regain students’ attention once the elf has taken center stage.
It’s Not Inclusive
Another reason Elf on the Shelf doesn’t belong in the classroom is that it simply isn’t inclusive. While many students celebrate Christmas, not all do, and Elf on the Shelf is deeply tied to this holiday tradition. Classrooms should be places where all students feel included, regardless of their cultural or religious background.
For students who don’t celebrate Christmas, Elf on the Shelf can make them feel left out. One teacher shared, “We do a kindness countdown to the break. Students love it, and it ties in with our values.” This shows how educators can create meaningful holiday traditions that include all students, focusing on values like kindness and empathy, which resonate with everyone, regardless of their beliefs.
Inclusivity in the classroom is essential, especially during the holidays when cultural and religious differences become more pronounced. By moving away from traditions that are centered around one holiday, we can create activities that unite the entire class, ensuring that no one feels excluded.
It Encourages Extrinsic Motivation Over Intrinsic Learning
At its core, Elf on the Shelf uses extrinsic motivation to influence student behavior. The elf “watches” students, encouraging them to behave well to avoid being on the “naughty” list. While this may seem harmless, it promotes external rewards rather than fostering intrinsic motivation—the internal desire to behave well and learn because it’s the right thing to do.
Research shows that relying on extrinsic motivation can be counterproductive. A study in the Journal of Educational Psychology found that students who are motivated by external rewards are less likely to develop a lasting interest in learning. Instead, they focus on the reward rather than the joy or value of the task itself. In the case of Elf on the Shelf, students behave because they know they’re being watched, not because they understand the importance of kindness, empathy, or respect.
One teacher shared their positive shift away from external motivators: “I’ve had several parents thank me this year for doing fun, but educational activities.” This highlights the importance of creating classroom traditions that engage students through learning and growth rather than temporary rewards or surveillance.
Better Alternatives to Elf on the Shelf
If Elf on the Shelf doesn’t belong in the classroom, what are the alternatives? Thankfully, there are plenty of options that bring the same sense of fun and excitement without the downsides.
- Kindness Elves: These elves focus on promoting daily acts of kindness instead of watching for “naughty” behavior. Each day, students are encouraged to complete small acts of kindness, which can be shared and celebrated in the classroom. This not only fosters positive behavior but also builds a sense of community and empathy.
- The Giving Manger: This tradition involves students performing good deeds and placing pieces of “straw” in a manger. By the end of the season, the collective actions of the students create something meaningful. This activity teaches students that their behavior has a positive impact on others, reinforcing values like generosity and service.
- Reindeer in Here: For teachers looking for something fun but less stressful, Reindeer in Here offers a festive alternative. Students engage with a reindeer companion during the holiday season without the pressure of daily surveillance. As one teacher shared, “Nope—my ELF brings the holiday fun by dropping off treats,” showing how some teachers have found low-maintenance ways to keep the holiday spirit alive without disrupting the classroom(Clarks Condensed)(Homeschool Super Freak)(This Mama Loves).
These alternatives promote inclusivity and learning while still bringing the joy of the season into the classroom—without the chaos.
Bringing Fun Back to the Classroom Without the Chaos
Holiday traditions are important, and they absolutely have a place in the classroom—but not at the expense of learning. Fun doesn’t have to mean chaos, and holiday excitement doesn’t have to come from a mischievous elf. There are plenty of ways to introduce holiday magic into the classroom that complement learning rather than detract from it.
One teacher shared, “Fun but educational activities have kept my students engaged without the hassle.” This shows that holiday traditions can be engaging and meaningful without overwhelming teachers or distracting students from their academic goals. Whether it’s introducing holiday-themed lesson plans or creating art projects related to global celebrations, there are countless ways to make the season magical while maintaining the focus on learning.
Conclusion
At the end of the day, Elf on the Shelf may seem like a fun addition to the classroom, but it often causes more distractions than it’s worth. The lack of inclusivity and reliance on extrinsic motivation make it a poor fit for an educational environment. Instead, teachers should embrace alternatives that promote kindness, inclusivity, and learning. From kindness initiatives to educational holiday traditions, there are countless ways to bring joy into the classroom without sacrificing the focus on growth and learning.
It’s time to rethink what “fun” really means in the classroom and ensure that our holiday traditions support learning, inclusivity, and growth for every student.
What holiday traditions do you use in your classroom? Share your ideas for making the holiday season magical, inclusive, and stress-free for both students and teachers.
6 Forgotten Subjects Teachers Desperately Want Back in Schools