I’ll never forget the day I decided to take away recess for the first time. It was one of those chaotic mornings where nothing seemed to go right. My students were restless, talking over me, and ignoring directions. I tried everything—redirecting their energy, lowering my voice, waiting for silence. Nothing worked. Finally, in a moment of pure frustration, I said, “That’s it. No recess today.” The room went silent, and I felt a mix of relief and guilt. Relief that I had finally regained control, but guilt because I knew recess was important for them. I started to wonder, “Am I doing more harm than good by taking away this time for them to run and play?”
Why Recess Is Essential
Recess isn’t just a break for students to burn off energy; it’s an essential part of their development. Studies show that physical activity improves cognitive function, social skills, and overall behavior. Removing this time can hinder a student’s ability to focus and engage in the classroom. Children need time to play, run, and let loose, so they can come back to class ready to learn. According to the CDC, kids need 60 minutes of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity daily, and recess plays a significant role in meeting this goal(TeacherHow).
Beyond physical activity, recess plays a critical role in social development. It’s the time when students practice conflict resolution, cooperation, and communication with their peers. By taking away recess, we might inadvertently limit their opportunities to build essential social skills.
One teacher said it best:
“Little kids need to run off some energy. Maybe a shorter recess, but don’t take it away completely.”
The Struggle to Manage Behavior Without Taking Recess Away
As teachers, we know how challenging it can be to manage a classroom full of active, sometimes unruly kids. There are days when no matter what we try, the students seem to push every button. For many of us, taking away recess becomes an easy way to regain control. But is it the right approach?
While taking recess away can be effective in the short term, it often doesn’t address the root of the behavior issue. In fact, removing recess might make things worse by depriving students of the physical outlet they need to manage their energy.
One teacher mentioned,
“I have done the same thing, although it was rarely the entire recess. It can be a great motivator for kids to think about being held accountable for their actions.”
However, managing behavior without removing recess isn’t always easy. Implementing alternatives might require additional effort, such as setting up a reflection space or organizing supervision for students walking laps. These solutions, while effective, might feel time-consuming in the moment. Yet, finding small ways to make these alternatives work can help preserve the balance between discipline and physical activity. For instance, assigning peer mentors to supervise or organizing quick “cool down” areas can alleviate the extra pressure on teachers.
Alternatives to Keep Kids Active While Addressing Behavior
Instead of taking away recess entirely, there are many creative alternatives that allow students to stay active while still addressing their behavior. Here are a few options:
- Reflection Time: Set up a reflection area during recess where students can sit and think about their behavior before joining the group again. This keeps them involved in the activity while encouraging introspection
- Walking Laps: Another great alternative is having students walk or run laps. This way, they are still engaging in physical activity, but with a focus on self-reflection. As one commenter shared, “I have them run or walk laps around the play area while the others play. That way, they can think about their day and actions.”
- Peer Mentorship: Pair students who struggle with behavior with more responsible peers. This creates an opportunity for positive behavior modeling and guidance during recess
While these alternatives may require some extra organization, the benefits of maintaining physical activity while addressing behavior far outweigh the challenges. Not only do students get the chance to reflect, but they also release energy, making it easier for them to return to the classroom ready to learn.
Why Teachers Need Recess as Much as Students
Recess isn’t just for the kids—teachers need that break too. It’s the time we use to recharge, reset, and mentally prepare for the rest of the day. Whether it’s to grab a quick snack, use the restroom, or just take a breather, recess is essential for us to maintain our own well-being in the classroom.
One teacher captured this perfectly:
“I don’t take away recess. Recess is my break too!”
When we take away recess from our students, we’re also taking away our own opportunity to reset. This can lead to teacher burnout and frustration, making it harder to be effective for the rest of the day.
Additionally, recess offers a chance for teachers to engage with students in a less formal environment, helping to build stronger teacher-student relationships.
Reward Good Behavior Instead of Punishing the Bad
One of the most effective ways to manage classroom behavior is through positive reinforcement. Instead of focusing solely on punishment, try rewarding students for good behavior. For example, students who consistently follow the rules could earn extra playtime or special privileges during recess. This creates a positive cycle where students are motivated to behave well in order to gain more freedom.
One strategy that works well is setting up a behavior chart where students can earn points or stickers for good behavior. At the end of the week, those points can be traded for extra playtime.
As one teacher suggested:
“Rewarding students for good behavior with more recess time creates a positive reinforcement cycle that makes them want to do better.”
Positive reinforcement doesn’t just improve behavior—it also builds a more positive classroom environment, making students feel valued and motivated to succeed.
Conclusion: Finding Balance Between Discipline and Play
Managing a classroom is never easy, and there will always be days when discipline becomes challenging. However, taking away recess may not always be the best solution. By incorporating creative alternatives, we can address behavior issues without sacrificing the benefits of physical activity for our students. Recess is a crucial part of their development, and with the right strategies, we can find a balance that supports both their need for play and our need for classroom control.
By protecting recess and implementing alternatives, we are fostering a healthier, more productive environment for both teachers and students. And with a little patience and creativity, we can ensure that discipline and play coexist.
Am I a Bad Teacher for Using Social Media in the Classroom?