As a teacher, I’ve spent countless hours preparing my students for the next big step in their education journey. But lately, there’s been a growing concern gnawing at the back of my mind. Despite their seemingly impressive GPAs, many of the students I’ve taught simply aren’t ready for the demands of college.
I’m not alone in this realization—teachers across the country are seeing the same worrying trend. Students are struggling, not just academically, but in the essential skills needed for higher education.
So, what’s happening in our classrooms, and what does this tell us about how we’re preparing the next generation?
The Disconnect Between GPA and True Readiness
As teachers, we’ve all seen it—students with stellar GPAs that don’t reflect their true academic abilities. It’s becoming increasingly clear that high school grades have become less reliable as indicators of college readiness. One teacher put it best: “We’ve lowered our expectations significantly.”
The issue of grade inflation isn’t new, but it has worsened in recent years. The pressure to maintain graduation rates, coupled with a shift toward more lenient grading practices during the pandemic, has created a situation where students are graduating with inflated GPAs. According to a recent study by the ACT, high school GPAs increased from 3.17 in 2010 to 3.36 in 2021, while standardized test scores have dropped(OnToCollege).
The result is a growing gap between students’ perceived readiness and their actual ability to succeed in college. A study from the University of California found that standardized test scores are still the best predictors of college GPA, sophomore retention, and degree completion(OnToCollege). As teachers, we know that a high GPA doesn’t necessarily mean a student has mastered critical thinking or problem-solving. These are the skills that will determine their success in college—not just the ability to perform well on tests.
The Pandemic’s Lasting Impact on College Readiness
The COVID-19 pandemic has left an indelible mark on education, and nowhere is this more apparent than in the readiness of students entering college. When schools moved to online learning, many students struggled to stay engaged, and those who were already on the edge fell further behind.
One high school teacher summarized the situation: “COVID turned barely working students into non-working ones.” This shift wasn’t just anecdotal. A study from the McKinsey Institute reported that students in the U.S. were on average five months behind in math and four months behind in reading by the end of the 2020-2021 school year(Inside Higher Ed). These gaps have persisted, leaving students entering college without the foundational knowledge they need.
Even more concerning is the phenomenon known as “Swiss-cheese learning”—where students have missed critical pieces of information, making it difficult for them to build on their knowledge. Many students didn’t receive the hands-on learning and immediate feedback that are crucial in subjects like math, science, and writing, leading to significant gaps in their readiness.
To bridge these gaps, schools must offer targeted interventions, such as remedial courses and tutoring programs, to help students catch up before they enter college.
Skills Deficit: What’s Missing in Today’s Education?
Academics aren’t the only area where students are struggling. Many of today’s high school graduates lack the practical skills necessary to thrive in college. These are the same life skills—time management, self-discipline, problem-solving—that are often learned outside the classroom, through experiences like extracurricular activities and part-time jobs.
One teacher pointed out: “This is due to the lack of skills training at an earlier stage.”
In recent years, schools have focused heavily on standardized testing and academic performance, but often at the expense of real-world skill development. As a result, many students know how to pass a test, but they struggle when faced with unstructured time, open-ended problems, or managing multiple assignments on their own.
One solution is to reintroduce more experiential learning into the classroom. Project-based learning, which encourages students to engage in real-world problems and develop critical thinking skills, is one approach that has shown promise. Schools can also partner with local businesses or community organizations to offer students opportunities for internships or volunteer work, which can help them develop the skills they’ll need in college and beyond.
The Role of Parenting and Expectations
Of course, the issue of readiness doesn’t rest solely on schools. Parenting plays a critical role in shaping how prepared students are for college. Over the years, we’ve seen a shift in parenting styles—what some call “helicopter parenting”—where parents are deeply involved in their children’s academic lives, often stepping in to solve problems on their behalf.
One teacher noted: “The way we are parenting is not preparing them for the real world.” While this approach comes from a place of love and concern, it can have unintended consequences. When students haven’t experienced failure or learned how to overcome challenges independently, they struggle when faced with the autonomy and responsibility required in college. They are accustomed to immediate support and intervention, which isn’t always available in a college setting.
As educators, we can help address this by fostering more independence in the classroom. Encouraging students to take ownership of their work, manage their time effectively, and face the consequences of their mistakes can help them build the resilience they’ll need for the challenges ahead. Parents, too, can contribute by stepping back and allowing their children to navigate difficulties on their own, preparing them for the realities of college life.
What Needs to Change Moving Forward?
So, where do we go from here? If we want to better prepare our students for college, we need to make some fundamental changes to how we assess readiness and develop essential skills.
First, we need to move beyond relying solely on GPAs and standardized test scores to gauge college readiness. More schools are starting to adopt holistic assessment methods that include indicators like extracurricular involvement, internships, and real-world projects. These methods provide a more comprehensive picture of a student’s readiness for life after high school(Edutopia).
Second, we need to focus on long-term skill development. This means incorporating more project-based learning, experiential education, and critical thinking exercises into the curriculum. Schools can also implement skill-building workshops to help students develop time management, organization, and problem-solving abilities.
Finally, we need to address the lingering effects of the pandemic on education. Offering remedial courses, tutoring, and mentoring programs can help students fill in the gaps left by remote learning and ensure they are better prepared for the academic challenges of college.
Conclusion
The college readiness crisis is a challenge that goes beyond academics. It touches on everything from how we grade, to the skills we teach, to how we parent. But by addressing these issues head-on, we can help our students not just succeed in college, but thrive.
As teachers, we have a responsibility to raise the bar, foster independence, and equip our students with the skills they’ll need in the real world. By working together—educators, parents, and policymakers—we can bridge the gap and ensure that our students are truly ready for the next step in their educational journey.
Why Students Struggle in Calculus: It All Comes Down to the Basics